
Reproductive Healthcare… Beyond Reproduction: Shaker Sister Prudence’s Health Manual for Her Fellow Sisters
The examination room was cold, but that was not why I was shaking. As a sophomore in college, I was trying, again, to get some help for my painful, very irregular periods. At nineteen years old, these symptoms had been dismissed for seven years by doctors. After talking to my college peers, I was ready to try again. I went in and tried to calmly explain my symptoms, making it clear that they were disruptive to my everyday life. The doctor, a woman, nodded along. When I finished speaking, she gave me a hard look and simply said, “Sounds like you’re just anxious.” She clicked her pen and marked something off her page. “Even if you have some sort of issue,” she said, “it will likely go away once you have a kid.”
That was it. For years afterward, I suffered with symptoms of amenorrhea, or the absence of menstruation, disruptive pain before and during menstruation, and severe premenstrual symptoms. I was twenty-seven when I finally received a diagnosis of PCOS: polycystic ovary syndrome. (In May, 2026, the name was officially changed to Polyendocrine Metabolic Ovarian Syndrome, PMOS). The relief of being believed didn’t last. When we discussed treatment, the options were almost entirely fertility-focused. As a child-free person by choice, I wasn’t interested in improving fertility. I just wanted to manage my symptoms. But in the eyes of my healthcare providers, reproduction was the focus of my chronic illness, and they disregarded my pain and discomfort.
This diagnosis happened while I was in graduate school and partway through my PhD program in history. A few months later, I sat in the archives at the Winterthur Library in Delaware, looking through the Shaker community collections. I was researching for my dissertation on women’s healthcare practices in intentionally organized religious communities in the early American republic when I came across a unique primary source. Prudence Morrell, a Shaker sister in New Lebanon, New York, wrote a medical manual in 1860 for her community’s celibate women.[1] It addresses menstruation, menopause, and mental health – but not childbearing. Unlike the manuals typically written for women in this era, Prudence’s guide omits pregnancy and birth entirely, since Shaker women were expected to remain celibate. For women who had rejected marriage and childbirth, reproductive healthcare took on a different meaning. Prudence’s medical guide offers a rare glimpse into a nineteenth-century approach to women’s health that did not center fertility but instead considered the everyday health and wellbeing of women.
This little green booklet challenged assumptions found in medical literature written by male physicians who increasingly tied menstruation to fertility and womanhood. As historian Nora Doyle explains, “sentimental motherhood,” the belief that the nature of a woman was to have children and raise them, became ingrained in the ideology of white, Christian citizens of the budding United States.[2] Male physicians further supported these beliefs about a woman’s nature by medicalizing the female body, further asserting that fertility indicated proper health. Moreover, regular menstruation also became associated with the ability to have children, and therefore embodied the ideals of womanhood. Nineteenth-century physician Thomas Cock, for example, described women who never menstruated as “unfeminine,” associating their conditions with masculine physical characteristics. He concluded that such conditions were not treatable and advised that these women “should not marry.”[3] For Shaker women, however, marriage and childbirth were not expected parts of life, even as menstruation, illness, and aging remained important concerns.
Shaker Sister and Physician Prudence Morrell
The United Society of Believers in Christ’s Second Coming (known colloquially as the Shakers) arrived in New York from England in the 1770s and established communities across New England, the Midwest, and Kentucky. The Shakers believed celibacy freed them from original sin. By rejecting marriage and sex, women could achieve spiritual equality with men and were freed from the continuous cycles of childbearing. Many women who joined the Shakers were already wives and mothers, but by joining, they could step outside the expected roles of wife and mother and enter a community organized around a shared religious life.[4]
The Shakers developed a robust healthcare system to ensure the survival of their communities. Ideally, “two brothers and two sisters” in each community were appointed to serve as physicians, with additional members serving as nurses. In some communities, such as that of Harvard, Massachusetts, sisters served as the primary physicians, relying on the occasional help of brothers.[5] Shaker physicians documented their treatments carefully, drew on both herbal traditions and outside medical texts, and approached healthcare with notable caution towards using harsh or invasive treatments.
Prudence Morrell came from one of the first families to join the Shakers in America. Her father, Calvin Morrell, was a physician who helped establish Shaker communities in Ohio, and Morrell likely learned some of her medical knowledge from him. She practiced medicine in Union Village (Ohio) and New Lebanon (New York), developing a respected career within the Shaker healthcare network. Over time, she collected medical recipes and treatments in books, including one written specifically for her fellow sisters.

Over time, Morrell collected her medical recipes and reflections in recipe books. She left behind two important medical texts, one for the entire community of New Lebanon, and one specifically for her Shaker sisters. Morrell’s Recipes of Counsels, organized into eighteen chapters, was intended for the latter. Each chapter includes a reflection and further instructions, advising when to change treatments or offering words of caution. She provides multiple recipes for syrups, powders, and pills to “regulate the menses,” or encourage menstruation. These treatments for amenorrhea all include herbal mixtures, a hint of alcohol, and different prescribed timeframes. In each case, the treatments were to be taken prior to expected menstruation, for varying lengths of time.
Morrell’s recipes reveal that Shaker women were likely keeping track of their menstrual cycles, despite not trying to conceive. After listing these treatments for amenorrhea, she explains to her sisters:
The above is for removing obstructions of the menses. Females are so constructed that they are not well, neither can they enjoy good health, unless they have their monthly courses, and every little thing will throw them further and further out of health.[6]
Morrell’s explanation reveals a Shaker interpretation of the female body and health. She was still influenced by humoral theory, the belief that health depended on maintaining balance within the body, and she shares the understanding of many contemporary physicians that menstruation was required for women’s health. She suggests that if a woman did not have a regular cycle, she would be susceptible to other ailments. However, her instructions also reveal that bringing back menstruation was not always the immediate priority. Taking into consideration the health of the woman suffering from amenorrhea, Morrell continues:
But when a person is very feeble in body, and not sufficient strength of blood to have their monthly turns, it would not be wisdom to administer the above medicines: the syrup may be given if any thing, or a syrup may be made of some strengthening roots and herbs, without any driving medicine in it.[7]
Morrell recognizes that some of these treatments were rather strong and could be damaging if a woman was weak. Taking these effects into consideration, she instead suggests administering a simpler treatment and addressing bodily weakness itself. Bringing back menstruation was necessary for restoring the overall health of the woman.
The difference in tone between Morrell’s instructions and the publications of physicians like Thomas Cock is striking. Unlike Cock, Morrell’s tone doesn’t suggest any inherent deficiency in women, nor does she focus on the effects of menstruation on fertility and how well a sister embodies womanhood. Instead, Morrell identifies menstruation as a natural function essential to a woman’s overall health. Her recommended treatments are equally noteworthy. She relies primarily on herbal remedies that women could have grown or obtained for themselves. Even though physicians such as Cock also recommended some herbal treatments, they were also inclined to utilize opium, mercury, and even leeches to treat disruptions in menstruation. When addressing cases of amenorrhea, Cock also suggests applying “leeches to the vulva.”[8] Indeed, these invasive treatments are not found in Morrell’s instructions, and strong medications like opium appear only in exceptional circumstances, when the loss of life is a concern. While herbal remedies were not necessarily safer or more effective than other nineteenth-century treatments, Morrell’s instructions reveal an effort to consider the condition of the woman before administering medicine. When addressing “flooding,” or excessive menstrual bleeding, her treatments include bitters, a powder, and a pill for the purpose of controlling heavy bleeding. Morrell prefaces these recipes with guidance regarding when to use these treatments, when to avoid them, and when to use something stronger.[9]
A Not-so-New Model for Women’s Healthcare?
Nearly two centuries later, women’s reproductive healthcare remains closely tied to fertility. My own experience seeking treatment for my condition, which is not unique, shows that this connection remains prevalent in women’s healthcare. Sitting in the archives at the Winterthur, reading the words of a nineteenth-century Shaker sister, I found another model. Morrell’s medical guide shows that women have, for centuries, challenged the assumption that women’s reproductive health must always be understood through their ability or desire to have children. Her work reminds us that women have long sought care for their bodies and their well-being, regardless of their reproductive choices.
Notes
- Prudence Morrell, “Receipts of Counsels, Exclusively for Female Diseases Selected by Prudence Morrell, When in the Sixty first year of her age,”1854, Document ASC 1016, Joseph Downs Collection of Manuscripts and Printed Ephemera, Winterthur Museum Libraries. ↑
- Nora Doyle, Maternal Bodies: Redefining Motherhood in Early America (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2018), 3–4. ↑
- Thomas F. Cock, A Manual of Obstetrics (New York: Samuel S. & Wm. Wood, 1853), 36-7. ↑
- Glendyne R. Wergland, Sisters in the Faith: Shaker Women and Equality of the Sexes (University of Massachusetts Press, 2011), 2; Lawrence Foster, Women, Family, and Utopia: Communal Experiments of the Shakers, the Oneida Community, and the Mormons, 23; French, Against Sex: Identities of Sexual Restraint in Early America, 88. ↑
- Merry B. Post, “Medical Practice in the Harvard Shaker Church Family 1834-1843,” American Communal Societies Quarterly 4, no. 4 (October 2010): 218-229, 218. ↑
- Prudence Morrell, “Receipts of Counsels,” 6. ↑
- Prudence Morrell, “Receipts of Counsels,” 7. ↑
- Thomas F. Cock, A Manual of Obstetrics, 42. ↑
- Prudence Morrell, “Receipts of Counsels,” 9. ↑
Featured image caption: Shaker booth group at Army Relief Bazaar, Albany, New York, 1864. (Courtesy Library of Congress)
Savannah Flanagan is a History Ph.D. student at Baylor University. She is currently studying religious communal groups and the implications of gender, medicine, and belief.
Discover more from Nursing Clio
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
